| Year | Quartet | Members | Chorus |
| 2008 | Lucky Day | Karen Tate LeeAnne Vance Holly Colón Kris Hawkins | Chapter-at-Large Region 4 & Pride of Kentucky |
| 2007 | On The Edge | Michelle Thistle Debbie Thistle Debbie Arnold Sue Pelley | White River Sound |
| 2006 | Moxie Ladies | Stacy St. John Jennifer Edwards Amy Leacock Gretchen Holloway | CAL Regions 4 & 17 & Scioto Valley |
| 2006 | On The Edge - Wildcard | Michelle Thistle Debbie Thistle Debbie Arnold Sue Pelley | White River Sound |
| 2005 | latté | Holly Harrington Tawni Miller Holly Colón Judy Norris | Gem City & Hocking Valley |
| 2004 | latté | Holly Harrington Tawni Miller Holly Colón Judy Norris | Gem City & Hocking Valley |
| 2004 | Smile - Wildcard | Stacey St. John Susan Martin Lynn Vaughn Nancy Shumard | CAL, River Blenders, Midwest Crossroads, Smoky Mountain Harmony |
| 2004 | Cosmopolitan - Wildcard | Tricia Wahl Norma Rash Kim Hoover Carey Coleson | CAL, Gem City & Pride of Kentucky |
| 2004 | On The Edge - Wildcard | Michelle Thistle Debbie Thistle Debbie Arnold Sue Pelley | White River Sound |
| 2003 | latté | Holly Harrington Tawni Miller Holly Colón Judy Norris | Gem City & Hocking Valley |
| 2002 | Success Express | Stacey St. John Michelle Jarrell Kerry Denino Gretchen Holloway | Scioto Valley & CAL |
| 2001 | Risky Business | Trish (Tilbury) Wahl Norma Rash Kim Hoover Carey Coleson | Gem City & Pride of Kentucky |
| 2000 | Risky Business | Trish (Tilbury) Wahl Norma Rash Kim Hoover Carey Coleson | Gem City & Pride of Kentucky |
| 2000 | The Rolling Tones - Wildcard | Holly (Miller) Harrington Tawni Miller Karen Johns Judy Norris | Gem City |
| 1999 | The Rolling Tones | Holly (Miller) Harrington Tawni Miller Karen Johns Judy Norris | Gem City |
| 1998 | Success Express | Stacey St. John Michelle (Holloway) Jarrell Kerry Denino Gretchen Holloway | Scioto Valley & Gem City |
| 1997 | Swinglish Mix | Eleanor Hawkins Suzanne Harrington Patty Hawley Naima Meyer | Pride of Kentucky & CAL #23 |
| 1996 | Crescendo | Karen Tate Joyce Doll Holly (Reiman) Colón Jane Ketover | Seven Hills |
| 1996 | Success Express - Wildcard | Holly (Miller) Harrington Michelle (Holloway) Jarrell Kerry Denino Gretchen Holloway | Scioto Valley & Seven Hills |
| 1996 | Replay - Wildcard | Libby (Blandford) Fagan Norma Rash Belinda Ray Margie Dimond | Pride of Kentucky & CAL #23 |
| 1996 | Syncopated, Inc. - Wildcard | Eleanor Hawkins Patty Hawley Melva Carter Carey Coleson | Pride of Kentucky |
| 1995 | Success Express | Holly (Miller) Harrington Michelle (Holloway) Jarrell Kerry Denino Gretchen Holloway | Scioto Valley & Seven Hills |
| 1994 | Success Express | Holly (Miller) Harrington Michelle (Holloway) Jarrell Kerry Denino Gretchen Holloway | Scioto Valley & Hocking Valley |
| 1993 | Success Express | Holly (Miller) Harrington Michelle (Holloway) Jarrell Kerry Denino Gretchen Holloway | Scioto Valley & CAL |
| 1993 | Artistry - Wildcard | Susan Blatchly Jean Barford Mary Rhea Deborah Kilander | Gem City |
| 1992 | Harmony Highlights | Debbie Hite Betty Lou Coleman Melva Carter Carey Coleson | Pride of Kentucky |
| 1991 | Harmony Highlights | Debbie Hite Betty Lou Coleman Melva Carter Carey Coleson | Pride of Kentucky |
| 1991 | Derbytown Sound - Wildcard | Kay Smith Belinda Ray Linda Brown Carolyn MacGregor | Derby City |
| 1990 | Changing Times | Carolyn Healey Joyce Doll Jill Allgeyer Barbara Phillipps | Seven Hills |
| 1989 | Harmony Highlights | Debbie Hite Betty Lou Coleman Melva Carter Carey Coleson | Pride of Kentucky |
| 1988 | Classic Choice | Susan Blatchly Jean Barford Jamie Ayers Judy St. John | Gem City |
| 1987 | Changing Times | Carolyn Healey Joyce Doll Jill Allgeyer Barbara Phillipps | Seven Hills |
| 1986 | Second Time Around | Meridy Thorn Debbie Wheeler Helen Hampe Karen (Hampe) Gatchell | Capital City |
| 1985 | Changing Times | Carolyn Healey Joyce Doll Jill Allgeyer Barbara Phillipps | Seven Hills |
| 1984 | Changing Times | Carolyn Healey Joyce Doll Jill Allgeyer Barbara Phillipps | Seven Hills |
| 1983 | Alumni Association | Jennie (Bradshaw) Watkins Lois Craddock Teresa (Gordon) Montgomery Kim Lawrence | River Magic |
| 1982 | Changing Times | Carolyn Healey Joyce Doll Jill Allgeyer Barbara Phillipps | Seven Hills |
| 1981 | Sound System | Meridy Thorn Karen (Hampe) Gatchell Helen Hampe Lu Senter | Capital City |
| 1980 | Belle-V-Dears | Joyce Feusner Ronnie Dunn Lou Purnell Helen (Logue) Taylor | Kentuckiana |
| 1979 | Front Porch Society | Arlene Kilpatrick Joan "Josie" Gatchell Joyce Scott Diana Tuck | Capital City |
| 1978 | Harmony Highlights | Debbie Hite Betty Lou Coleman Melva Carter Dodie Florence | Falls of the Ohio |
| 1977 | Free Spirits | Jo Slagle Sheryl Wagner Mary Ann Fickenwirth Judy Cartwright | All American City |
| 1976 | Cheerios | Jo Ford Shirley Smith Suzy (Moorehead) Harding Betty Wolf | Clermont County |
| 1975 | Metro-Tones | Nancy Hasamear Edith (Edie) Bailey Pat White Joy Nabi | Metro Nashville |
| 1974 | Cardinal IV | Bernice (Jackson) Orr Vicki Pendleton Pat Humphrey Liz (O'Hara) Reed | Kentuckiana |
| 1973 | Love 'N Sound | Donna Hartmuth Lynn Hartmuth Sherri Strauss Judy (Hulbert) Davis | Seven Hills |
| 1972 | Silver Sounds | Carolyn Healey Ruth Doll Norma Mundstock Barbara Phillipps | Seven Hills |
| 1971 | Sounds of Music | Jean (Pyles) Barford Gloria LaQuaglia Edie (Walters) Moorehead Judy St. John | Gem City |
| 1970 | Derbytown Four | Murna (Bunnell) Watkins DeShea (Wilson) Patrick Bunny Johnson Carolyn MacGregor | Kentuckiana |
| 1969 | Christofour | Sandy Eisenhart Cam Karau Linda Fausey Sandy Reeser | Columbus |
| 1968 | Enchanters | Dana Gentil Kay Velker Janice (Humphrey) Bailey Joyce Fortney | Seven Hills |
| 1967 | Verse-A-Dolls | Patty Reed Lila Corwin Betty Sue Whittaker Ruth Helmburg | Lexington |
| 1966 | Travelaires | Dee Bennison Mary Ellen Guntzelman Norma Mundstock Juanita Winstel | Seven Hills |
| 1965 | Derbytones | Sherron (Hammond) Tillman DeShea (Wilson) Patrick Geraldine (Brown) Noble Carolyn MacGregor | Kentuckiana |
| 1964 | Rain Checks | Dana Gentil Barbara Herrmann Ginny Heinekamp Barb Strubbe | Seven Hills |
| 1963 | Piper-Ettes | Carolyn (Morter) Sexton Ruth Doll Kitty Bawtenheimer Carol Simons | Seven Hills |
| 1962 | Four of Hearts | Patty Spencer Shirley Henrichsmeyer Judy Leschewski Wanda Pugh | Decatur |
| 1961 | Perky-Laters | Carolyn (Morter) Sexton Judy Martin Ruth Allen Ginny Blair | Kettering |
| 1960 | Deck-A-Kords | Judy Jordan Faye Madden Ann McPhee Lorena Davison | Capital City |
| 1959 | Deca-Tones | Helen Ryan Esther Hesler Jean Freeman Virginia Knight | Decatur |
| 1958 | Indi-Anns | Doris Marbach Mary Dalgleish Marilyn Hedges Helen Neidlinger | Capital City |
| 1957 | Miss Chiefs | Elaine Eveling Marge Kile Jan Johnston Judy Conrad | St. Louis |